Michael`s Diner in Windham

5339 State Route 23, Windham, NY 12496-5906, Windham

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Diner
  • Vegetarian Friendly

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Michael`s Diner
PP
Poop Poop
google
11.20.2024
5/5

Best diner ever

Michael`s Diner
DK
Debra Kaufman
google
09.19.2018
5/5

Excellent place to eat, great menu and lots of specials. You will not be disappointed! Atmosphere friendly, hometown kind of place.

Michael`s Diner
VS
Vincent Scarduzio
google
09.14.2018
5/5

New favorite place to eat in windham. Portions are big and prices are great. Staff is great!!

Michael`s Diner
JV
Jorge Vega
google
09.05.2018
4/5

Great food, great service, cash only.

Michael`s Diner
SM
Steven Max
google
08.21.2018
5/5

The service is great, the food is even better. Been here at least twenty times and its always wonderful. Pulled pork and pita pizzas are my go-to.

Michael`s Diner
JV
Jenny Vesta
google
07.18.2018
3/5

Used to be Michael's diner now its Windham Diner. Prices went up now that they cater to wealthy tourists coming to the "Aspen" of NY. If you share a plate with a kid they make you buy something like a side dish or they charge you for the kid. Kind of odd. Place is old yet quaint. They need new booth seats too.

Michael`s Diner
SD
Stephen DeStef
google
07.01.2018
2/5

Walked into an active dining room at 8:10 PM as the Google posted closing time is 9PM. The owner shouts to the waitress across the room " go see what this guy wants"...really, is it that much of a stretch? Door open, no signs or other indication that they closed at 8PM. I guess business is good when you can rudely turn away repeat customers..

Michael`s Diner
MP
Matthew Penniman
google
06.19.2018
5/5

Love my pita pizza

Michael`s Diner
ws
william sprossel
google
05.16.2018
4/5

Walked with party of five... Warm summer evening, and AC was not working properly... We seated ourselves, and waitress was very terse when she came and took our order... They had lots of special's and they were all excellent... I tried ordering the children's chicken strips, but waitress shut me down without a by your leave... So of all the meals mine was the worst, just frozen strips.. but everyone else was very pleased... The owner then sent us over a free dessert of lemon filled call which was good... If not for the waitress and the AC I would say this was an excellent place

Michael`s Diner
NM
Nadine M
google
05.04.2018
3/5

Disappointed! This was one of our favorite places. We had family visiting, Friday night December 28, 4 adults 2 kids. I went in. Across the room the owner yelled “what do you need” I said table for 6. He replied in a nasty tone it was too busy and had no room. I asked how long if we waited? Still nasty...no there’s no room. I left and probably won’t return.

Michael`s Diner
MM
Michele Massotti
google
04.20.2018
5/5

One of my favorite in Windham. Huge selection of food (wait to see the specials board they pull out, never ending). Portions are very generous, and we got free dessert twice. I tried both the gyro and the meatloaf, both delicious and super filling. My kids had French toast, and I gotta say it smelled delicious (think cinnamon sugar). My wife had a tuna salad wrap (awesome, since it was not too dry but no even too full of mayo) and a turkey burger with pita. I will definitely go back on my next trip to Windham.

Michael`s Diner
CM
Carlos Morales
google
04.15.2018
5/5

Greate food excelent services good prices

Michael`s Diner
KK
Kris King
google
03.18.2018
5/5

Great food , large portions enough for two meals. Sevice is excellent. Keep in mind cash only and no sharing of plates. Really inexpensive to eat. Gyros, Crab Caked, and Meatloaf.

Michael`s Diner
JA
James Allan
google
03.15.2018
4/5

Omelets here are to die for. Classic diner with a home like feel. I would come here again in the winter for snowboarding season!

Michael`s Diner
SM
Samantha Moses
google
03.11.2018
5/5

They had big portions and good food

Michael`s Diner
CD
Chris Delucia
google
01.25.2018
4/5

Good food and great service!!!

Michael`s Diner
LC
LeeAnn Corcoran
google
01.09.2018
5/5

Great place and food is so delicious. If u leave there hungry it's your own fault .

Michael`s Diner
CJ
Chris J
google
01.08.2018
5/5

Always reliable. Great food, large portions, reasonable prices. Been going for years. Great for large groups. Their dinner specials are fantastic, and you can't beat their weekday lunch specials.

Michael`s Diner
EP
Elizabeth Perri
google
09.24.2017
5/5

We really love going to Windham Diner! The food and family atmosphere can't be beat. We really appreciated that they were open this Thanksgiving and made a meal better than home cooking! Thank you everyone at Windham Diner...we will be back soon.

Michael`s Diner
AS
Aj Saitta
google
09.01.2017
5/5

Great food, hard working owner and staff, prices can't be beat.

Michael`s Diner
JD
Jack Davidson
google
07.19.2017
4/5

Great Different Sandwiches with Pork, Fish, Chicken, Steak, and Deep Fried Ribs!!

Michael`s Diner
HS
Hunter Stump
google
07.05.2017
5/5

This place has the best food and a wide variety. Super nice people - highly recommend

Michael`s Diner
RH
Richard Hatfield
google
06.25.2017
5/5

Food is great, service is the best, owners are the best. Would recommend anyone to eat there great food

Michael`s Diner
EM
Emily MacKinnon
google
06.09.2017
4/5

In the area for one night and stopped by for dinner. I have to eat gluten free and I was pleased that the waitress was both very knowledgeable and willing to accommodate my needs with what they have available. There were plenty of options. The food was decent, and the portions rather large. Not very expensive but the only take cash.

Michael`s Diner
BS
Blaise Schatzel
google
06.09.2017
5/5

Huge portions of delicious food. Best diner within an hours drive. One warning though, they are cash only.

Michael`s Diner
RP
Robert Price
google
05.07.2017
5/5

Loved it. Good was good. And a free desert to boot.

Michael`s Diner
NA
Nasseer Ali
google
05.02.2017
5/5

Good food, fair prices and friendly staff, warning cash only! There's a bank down the block.

Michael`s Diner
TG
Tyler Garrett
google
04.25.2017
3/5

This place is a pretty typical diner. Food is good but not anything special. I tend to get eggs benedict anywhere I'm eating breakfast, especially at a diner and it was overall enjoyable, but they overcooked the egg, so the yolk was not runny. Also my friend was never brought his food and had to ask them again for it. They simply forgot. I like this place but for the service, it's a little overpriced.

Michael`s Diner
reminissamber
google
04.23.2017
5/5

Great food , not what you expect from a diner, more like a restaurant.

Michael`s Diner
PK
Peter Koczarski
google
04.19.2017
5/5

Great place to get good food and good service. Went there today for the first time and was impressed. The portions are big with reasonable prices and the server that we had was attentive and nice. I would recommend coming here to eat if you are in the Windham area.

Michael`s Diner
KH
K. H.
google
04.14.2017
5/5

My first time there.Great food ,huge portions. Nice servers.

Michael`s Diner
PH
Peng Hsu
google
02.23.2017
4/5

I came here twice!! Both were on the ski vacation at Windham. The food we ordered were delicious and well served. Quantity were enough to stuff your stomach. I did enjoy the warm hospitality on my meal at the cold winter night then.... Recommended!!...

Michael`s Diner
KM
Kristie Morris
google
02.14.2017
5/5

Cute place, went for breakfast both days of our vacation. Staff super friendly, got eggs, pancakes, omletes and french toast, all was amazing. Prices r reasonable, highly recommend.

Michael`s Diner
dsonk
google
11.25.2016
5/5

Amazing food! Amazing service! Amazing atmosphere! Its all great. The portions are very big and everything is always fresh and delicious. Always have a great time here. I have been coming here for as long as I can remember and I dont have a single bad memory here. 10/10 amazing.

Michael`s Diner
DS
David Steele
google
11.16.2016
2/5

Breakfast cost me 25$ pricey, was not impressed with the food or freshness, better off at the steakhouse next door

Michael`s Diner
BO
Barbara Osterhoudt
google
11.09.2016
5/5

Great food good service. Very nice people

Michael`s Diner
LL
Life Life
google
11.05.2016
4/5

Nice local place. Great grill chicken salad

Michael`s Diner
MW
Mike Walma
google
11.02.2016
1/5

Sat down and ordered my food. Once I went to the register to pay I was told they do not take C/C and are Cash only. I was forced to walk 5 minutes down the street to an ATM. I went back and as I was paying I notified the owner he should have a simple sign that says cash only upon entering and he fought me on it and was very rude. The owner is incredibly self-less and egotistic. Horrible customer service and will never go back.

Michael`s Diner
CK
Chris Keff
google
10.09.2016
5/5

Great food, great service, great owners!

Michael`s Diner
EH
Ellen Hill
google
09.17.2016
5/5

It was a great meal and experience! Kudos to the waitress who helped us figure out the ATM!!! We owe you one!!

Michael`s Diner
DM
Debra Maynard
google
08.26.2016
5/5

Be hungry! You will have very generous portions. Everything is always fresh. Delicious fresh salads, coffee is always hot and fresh. Very clean comfortable for elderly and children. Very accommodating beautiful view. Parking is easy. They support the community wonderful people work here. Prices are family friendly. Get your favorite Greek food here! Have breakfast, lunch,diner. Burgers are outstanding. If you have a family to feed eat here you will eat well and have take home extras.

Michael`s Diner
tp
tea p
google
06.17.2016
5/5

Incredible selection of food choices, really nice atmosphere and very friendly, helpful staff.

Michael`s Diner
ML
M LW
google
06.11.2016
5/5

Amazing food, great service. Went on New Years and it was fabulous.

Michael`s Diner
ES
Elmira Shmeikhilman
google
06.07.2016
5/5

sweetest people on planet Earth. the owner has helped my husband and I so much with a place to stay, the food is delicious, huge portions for a great price and everyone is super friendly in the staff. it's incredible how sweet these people are. i would recommend this lil cozy diner to anyone any day. god bless everyone who works here. tip big if you do come! :)

Michael`s Diner
JM
J M
google
05.10.2016
5/5

I was passing through Windham New York to lay over and decided to have dinner here huge portions for the money I highly recommend this place

Michael`s Diner
JG
James Garofallou-Hogan
google
04.21.2016
5/5

Overall all friendly and welcoming with great food. Ask for Vicki; an awesome, friendly and funny server.

Michael`s Diner
BK
Brian K Hall
google
03.02.2016
3/5

Way overpriced and doesn't accept credit cards. This is 2020 not 1970

Michael`s Diner
SK
Scott Kelly
google
02.05.2016
5/5

Great food, small town cozy service. Awesome

Michael`s Diner
AD
Allae Dorion
google
01.15.2016
5/5

staff is wonderfully kind and attentive...food was perfectly prepared 🧡

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 15187344831

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!